As a matter of course, I do not generally discuss serious topics or the dreaded "blogging about blogging" here (KILL MEEEEE!), but circumstances of late compel me to do so now.
I started this blog for one simple reason: I was bored on maternity leave with T. That's it. I always loved to write, and was a literature major. In the past, if something funny would transpire on my way to work, I would basically turn it into a play in eight acts which I'd then email to my friends. While on maternity leave, I had just discovered the existence of blogs. It was just me and T, all day every day, and while I loved spending time with my bebe, none of my other local friends had kids yet, and I felt like I was slowly losing myself. Once I began reading blogs in earnest, I felt as though I’d discovered a whole world of hilarious/heartrending all-around incredible writing, and I thought to myself, "You know? I miss writing. I think I can do this, too."
My blog sort of sucked at first, but I found my groove; it got better, and I gained readers. I built friendships. I got to express myself—as sappy as it sounds--and my little blog that only my mom and husband read at first gained steam.
While I had no delusions or grand aspirations of making this blog The Next Big Thing, I did (and do) work hard to make my blog as good as it can be. Yes, I post infrequently, but that’s solely because I only post when I feel that I have something to say. I truly envy the people who have the fortitude to post quality writing daily, but that's just not me. Regardless, I never publish any post without spending significant time refining it and ensuring I convey my point (be it a treatise on my being a working mom, or my poetic ode to Road House) without ensuring that I've written it to the best of my (limited) abilities.
The point of all this is to clarify something very important: That statement regarding the time and effort I spend on posts extends to any and all reviews or endorsements that I choose to do here and on my review blog. I feel it is imperative to convey this because somehow, a number of people are under the impression that reviewing products (and running ads) on your blog makes you a "sellout". Unbeknownst to me--at least until recently-- the image of the mommyblogger (and I fucking hate that word) standing there with greedy hands out, mindlessly grasping for freebies and cash is apparently and unfortunately out there, and while I cannot and would not presume to speak for a group, I will do whatever small part I can to eradicate that by sharing with you my own policies related thereto.
As my blog has grown, I've been approached more and more frequently by companies/publishers wanting me to review products. I can unequivocally tell you that I say no far more often than I say yes. When I say yes, it’s not because I know in advance that I can give a favorable review about the product, but rather, that it's something I need/want/am interested in knowing more about. I work full time, have a husband and two small children. The majority of my time is devoted to my family and my job. This blog is a hobby, and a fun one at that. Why on earth would I waste MY precious free writing time and the time of a company taking something I know I don't need or want for the sake of having a "control group" of reviews, or some such shit? Or taking something I've used in the past and dislike? Isn't THAT problematic and disingenuous? Isn't my time far better spent accepting items from a company whose products I stand a chance of liking? And isn’t my time far better spent crafting posts about things I’ve enjoyed? To those who believe that acceptance of a product tacitly guarantees a favorable review, I direct you to my most recent post on my review blog. I don't bullshit just because I get something for free. That post is a prime example of an honest review. It contains positive points, yes, but it also contains detailed descriptions of issues and problems I had with the site that I was reviewing. It was done in a respectful, courteous manner, though, and I’m therefore satisfied with both the review and my personal integrity.
Furthermore, I stand behind everything I post, in terms of content, as well as quality. I have never and will never post a review or recommendation written in what I believe to be, for me, a subpar fashion, all but saying, “ProductXwassosuperterrificcanIpleasehavemymoneynowthanks.”I worry over each sentence in a review post in precisely the same way that I do a standard blog post. They’re my words, and I don’t want to look bad. And in the interest of full disclosure, I also always ensure that reviews are clearly marked as such, and convey whether or not I was paid and/or received free product in exchange for my post. The bottom line is that I will always write honest reviews. It is the prerogative of the company whether or not they choose to use them.
As for running ads on my blog, I don’t feel that I’ve compromised myself or given up a piece of my blog to have them. For instance, it’s clear that I occasionally curse on this blog. Certain advertisers won’t run ad campaigns on blogs that use expletives. Does that mean fewer ad revenue dollars for me here and there? Certainly. But I’m not going to censor myself over that. Say what you will about me, but I like getting a check every month from my ads. It affords me the opportunity to BUY EXTRANEOUS SHIT THAT I WANT. And I have absolutely no problem admitting that.
Blogs are by definition personal, so as I indicated above, I’m speaking only for myself here. I know that when we leave our blogs open to the public, we subject ourselves to judgment and scrutiny. To that end, I felt compelled to share with you my own experience and policies about products, reviews, and ads. To the extent that someone still thinks that people like me are sellouts or whores for free products and money, by mere virtue of the fact that we do reviews or have ads on our sites, so be it. But once I realized that impression existed out there AT ALL, I felt compelled to do what I could to clarify where I personally stand on this matter.
Monday, December 15, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)






40 comments:
I haven't been reading your blog for very long, but I just wanted to let you know that when it comes to product reviews, I truly enjoy reading about what other real women think. I have enjoyed your posts on regular subjects, and you've made me laugh. You also seem like a real person to me - someone whom I would trust the opinion of if we knew each other in "real life." So for me, product review is helpful and positive - because it comes from someone that I believe I can trust. I mean, heck - I've gotten more make-up tips and product ideas from the blogger that I read than any other source - and I trust them more, than say, InStyle magazine. I'm sorry if you feel that you've been criticized for providing this service - but I wanted to let you know that there is one reader (at the least I'm sure) that relies upon you. So thank you!
A girl has to do what a girl has to do for shoes and shiny things. More power to ya!
I applaud you. If people are going to judge you and what you are putting on your blog (first of all - how dare them) they really need to find something better to do. It's the internet, they can find SOMETHING out there that satisfies their shitty taste.
Meanwhile, I am loving you and your blog from over here in Portland.:) Review on, blog on and be yourself-on.
One of my favorite parts about this whole blogging gig is that so many of us are here for the same reasons, yes, sometimes, but also because so many of us are here for so many different! reasons, all of which are equally valid in my opinion.
There are so many different bloggers out there right now, writing on so many different topics and on so many different levels, and a lot of times those topics and levels evolve, which again to me seems quite natural and pretty awesome, actually, that this medium seems able to grow with the many who have chosen to put so much time and effort into it.
I have a one-line response to anyone who questions why I would have ads on my site (fortunately, this happens less and less): Where I come from, writers get paid to write.
I find it insulting that anyone would think that we should write or work for free. I think it's ridiculous that readers would be so paranoid as to think that your disclosure on a review wasn't anything but an elaborate hoax to... well... I don't know, lie to your readers? Devalue your own review? Right, of course.
I wouldn't worry about losing readers so easily offended when you're gaining ones who like you for who you are. (But of course, that's easy for me to say, innit?)
First of all, I am just now noticing the new look so if this is old news, apologies and also SO CUTE. Love it!
Secondly, I never thought you were "selling out" and honestly, if this is in reference to Kim's latest posts, I really don't think she meant that. I read the same post and took it a different way. I guess that's the beauty of blogging, right? We can all express our views and tastes for anyone to enjoy (hopefully).
I don't have an issue with blog ads as long as they don't compromise the look of the blog itself. Some blog pages get SO busy that it hurts my eyes. Sometimes the busiest blogs don't even have advertising, they are just ugly. And with that, please see my first point. :-)
i like where you stand, miss.
can i stand with you?
:)
It is so utterly ridiculous that you even have to explain this. Infuriating in fact. People should be able to do what they want, even if it does mean selling the fuck out (which obviously, you aren't, but you know). If you think someone is a sell out, STOP READING. Don't write some nasty little post, or leave them a bitchy comment about it. Just stop reading.
And as someone who writes a ton of reviews, MOSTLY FOR FREE with no compensation even in the form of a free product, I can say that my readers constantly tell me they love these posts. If they didn't, I wouldn't write them.
I judge you day in and day out. Anyone who doesn't share sample products with family members should reevaluate their priorities. I change the diapers of your bebes and what do I get in return? Nothing. OK maybe I don't change diapers, but still. We're family. At least we were.
are people giving you crap?! because whatever! i love your blog and your product reviews and your writing. no matter whatever you write about, i'll keep reading!
What is wrong with people? I will read anything you write, even your grocery shopping list- because you're a damn good writer.
Also? Remind me to never piss you off. :)
I don't get the brouhaha about ads at all at this point. Or paid blogging gigs. Or even reviews, because although I don't do them, they look like they're FUN, whether you get paid or not.
And before I say this next portion, I must add that I am mystified as to why any of this vitriol would be directed at YOU, because you've always been transparent, and even with bigger giveaways, like the Wii, you maintain who you are. So, I ask, who cares? Or, more importantly, WHO HAS TIME TO CARE? I want that kind of time.
That being said ...
Where I think a lot of the weird hostility comes from is that there is a weird little faction of the m'bloggers -- who, by the way, do not run in our same bloggish circle -- that only comes out at big events (J&J comes to mind), where they offer very conflicting messages like, "I can't be bought! This is my personal site!" while also strangely saying, "If a PR person wants to pitch me, they'd better make it WORTH MY WHILE!" and whining that they didn't get offered the free car/trip/ice cream/whatever.
Much as I hate to say this, I think with the freebies/paid blogging gigs, a lot of the anger comes from envy, and I don't say that lightly. I'm not one of those people who thinks jealousy is the reason for most female/female hostility, but in this case, I think the green shoe fits. Because I'm sorry, I really don't think there are that many people who are way into blog integrity. My guess is that they're pissed that THEY aren't getting ad revenue/free shit/whatever. I mean, why else would they CARE?
And finally, I will say that the only time ads/reviews have really bothered me is when that's all the blog is about and the person is completely lost. Even with that said, I can think of one -- ONE -- blogger in a sea of bloggers I've read over the last seven years that I've been reading blogs. So please. This is so not a rampant issue. Review away.
And finally, because I didn't write enough above apparently, when I ask the question, Why else would they care?, I mean that I'm assuming that THEY PERSONALLY choose not to do things for whatever reason, but I can't, for the life of me, figure out why they'd give a shit about what other people do if they were truly happy with that decision.
I mean, I don't do a lot of the extra bloggy stuff like reviews and such, but it's not necessarily for altruistic reasons (more like time, interest, other shit going on, etc.) and I CERTAINLY don't give a rip what other people do. Ergo, I am struggling to find a non-envy related reason why someone else would, other than a giant pole up their ass, which is a reason I had not previously considered. So! Problem solved: POLE.
Rock on, sista. I hear ya on the ad thing. We're writing content FOR FREE that no one is PAYING to read, using our FREE TIME to pen said prose, so why shouldn't we get a little compensation for that? (Said by the girl who currently has no ads!)
I think you're awesome, and I love everything about you and your lovely blog. Keep it up!
I don't understand why people instantly accuse bloggers who add advertisements to their blogs of selling out. It's why I've been so hesitant to place ads on my own blog. It's not like anyone (with the exception of Dooce and other extremely popular bloggers) makes enough to support themselves off of the ads. We're not talking about large sums of money. We're talking about a few extra dollars here and there. Honestly, what's the big fuss about?
Thanks to everyone who has commented so far for your thoughtful and insightful take on things. While I wrote this to simply state where I stand on the matter, it IS nice to know that a lot of people see eye-to-eye with me on this.
I do have to point out to those who have asked me here and via email that while reading a blog post about the matter somewhere else is in fact what precipitated this, it was NOT directed at me, personally. Since, however, the post in question did utilize the phrase "sellouts" to classify this group into which I felt I was, directly or indirectly, being lumped, I determined that it was necessary for me to clarify my policies and thoughts on this (apparently thorny) issue.
It's YOUR blog, write what you want. That's what amazes me about blogger hate mail. Don't like it, don't like the blog, don't read it!
Great post!
That's a great post. I have only recently started putting ads/doing reviews on my blog. The only reviews I've done have been through payperpost, and I could have done at least a dozen more from that site, but they were either for things I had no interest in, or with which I disagreed.
I also make a point of having at least as many (normally more) "regular" posts than review posts.
Your blog is so genuine and I love your sassy style! And hello, ads generate money for the lip gloss fund?!
In all seriousness, just keep doing what you are doing. Which it sounds like you are going to do:)
The only time ads on your site have bugged me was when they were misbehaving and covering up the post itself. People are complaining about this? And implying you're a sellout for being lucky enough to get free stuff? Man, that sucks. Don't sweat it, lady.
"Blogs are by definition personal"
Exactly. We are allowed to say whatever we want on our OWN blogs.
As for free reviews, who doesn't like free stuff? Anyone who says they wouldn't take something for free is a liar.
As for ads on blogs, almost every website has ads - CNN, NY Times, etc. I have ads because why not make a few extra pennies (and really people, it is PENNIES) off something you're going to do anyway? Because I have to pay hosting fees and for my domain name. So why not make some cash to offset those costs?
Metalia - I found your blog via Whoorl, and I must say that you two are my blog faves. Your sense of humor and take on life as it happens is hilarious...often times I'll think, "That's how I feel too!", but could never put it into words the way you do. I think what you are doing with your blog is great on many levels...
Creative expression - Check, Hilarious - Check, Cute kiddos - MAJOR check, Ad revenue - Again, check. You're not a sellout. Period. You are being business savvy, and getting to write at the same time. Win, win, yes? I wonder if it is a jealousy thing on the part of the person who initiated this. Upset b/c they want what others have been given...that's what I think it's about.
Anyway, keep doing what you are doing!
Hugs,
Michelle
Bravo!! You tell 'em, Metalia.
Hmm. I am wondering what it says about me that I kind of want ads on my blog (but have no idea how to go about getting them up there and would be a little shocked if anyone wanted to put them there to begin with)?
I too only blog when I actually have something to say, and I have to do a lot of tweaking to make sure my posts are worthy of publishing. I also envy those who can write really well, every day. And I don't think someone who has ads on their blog is a sell out. Cheers!
Frequent reader, infrequent commenter here. I read the post on that other blog that prompted this, and all I have to say is you are so right! Rock on, girl.
I don't care if bloggers have ads on their blogs or not. Bloggers who are mothers, not mothers, purple people eaters, I read the blogs because I enjoy the blogger's writing, topics, stories and sense of humor! To ad or not to ad seems totally moot. You choose to put ads on your site and I choose to read your site. No one should care about either of those choices as they don't affect other's lives personally. KEEP ON BLOGGING and enjoy the holidays with your family!
I feel the same way. I don't see what's wrong with having ads. If you don't want to read them, then don't. If you're interested, click the ad. It's that simple.
As for reviews, once holiday shopping started (somewhere around Halloween) I started getting a lot of requests. Four just yesterday. You know how many I've done? One. One book that I really wanted to read. I am not going to take whatever comes along, just because it's free. If others want to, then that's fine with me too. It doesn't make them a sell-out, it just makes their blog more about product reviews than writing. And, there's nothing wrong with that either.
Since I know this post was related to what I wrote, I wanted to say thank you for writing this. I have always appreciated your well thought out writing.
HATERS SUCK! And don't forget how educational your blog is too! I've learned so much from "Ask a Jew"! Just don't stop posting. You are by far the funniest blogger around... YAY METALIA.
This post is yet another reason to love you.
Perfectly said.
:)
metalia- you are the effing coolest.
god, i wish i could like, hang out with you in parking lots tailgating and whatnot. what a silly idea! but it would be AWESOME.
ps now that im on vacation (yeaaaahhh winter break- for all other readers, yes im a mere 23 year old college student, so sue me. i DARE you), i get to spend even more time looking back at metalia archives. does that make me dorky? yes. but i am also spending today (first day of vaca) starting off with a hefty metalia dosage and then off to sephora with 4 girlfriends to play. i cant wait! hahah
I think it's good that people are talking about this. Blogging is evolving, and companies are taking notice of bloggers and their readership.
I'm not here to debate whether this new evolution is good or bad. As someone who combs reviews from trusted sources before I make a big purchase...I feel I need to add my comment for WHATEVER it's worth.
I hear people say they wouldn't publish a review on something they didn't like. I (personally) value mixed or negative reviews just as much as positive ones. I'd like to know something good to try out AND! I'd *really* like to know what to avoid ;) Overall, I prefer constructive feedback, and decide for myself.
Seems that credibility is what we all want. So, if the big hoopla is whether or not a reviewer is being genuine... providing balanced feedback is the best way to maintain credibility.
Honestly, I'd put ads on my site... if I was smart enough to figure out how to do it. But I'm not. Would I gladly accept the extra cashola? You better believe it.
More power to you for saying what you think. We heart you.
Awwwwwwwwwwwwww snap... You go girl... :)
This is a great post. I do product reviews and I am unable to do a "balanced" post -ie the product is horrendous and I will never use it - I let the company know. In several instances they have appreciated my feedback and wanted to work with me to improve their product.
Imho if people have criticism because you decide to monetize and/or do product reviews then it is their prerogative to go elsewhere for their blog reading.
Keep doing what you are doing.
F the haters!
It's funny, I don't even notice ads on people's blogs anymore. Why is this even an issue for people? EVERYONE has ads.
(Except me. But not because I'm too cool for school - because I am LAZY!)
And as far as contests and such? That's simply sharing the love!
Speaking of, when are you giving away that Wii?! :)
I don't know who these people are who have been calling you a sellout, but they are stupid. And you are awesome. Product reviews are half the reason I read blogs.
Carry on.
Word.
I can't stop thinking about this and how well written and well said and well argued this was. It was great for you to stand up and put it out there - even if it is silly that people would ever generate questions that would lead to this response - but it is what it is.
Post a Comment